Mediating Real Estate Disputes – 5 Tips

In California, most buyers and sellers of residential and multifamily real estate use the California Association of Realtor’s standardized purchase and sale agreements and accompanying deal documents. While these forms can be customized, many of the typewritten (boilerplate) terms rarely change. One such term is the mediation provision.   The mediation provision requires the parties to participate in mediation before filing a lawsuit. If a party fails to participate in mediation prior to filing or defending a lawsuit, then that party will be barred from recovering their prevailing party attorneys’ fees (being reimbursed their attorneys’ fees spent in the litigation or arbitration) in the event they win the whole case.

Mediation can be thought of as a settlement conference. Here are 5 important things to know about mediation:

  1. Decision Makers Must Be Present. In order for the mediation to be successful the parties who control the decision-making must be present. Typically for real estate related mediations this means the buyer and seller or the landlord and tenant.     We have participated in mediations where the parties were located out of state and the mediator and parties stipulated to a mediation by webconference.


  1. It is Not Binding Unless The Parties Reach an Agreement.   During a mediation the mediator does not rule on the case or reach an actual decision as to who wins and who loses. Instead, the only decision the parties make is whether they will agree to settle the case on terms that all parties can mutually agree upon at mediation. That means that if one party does not like the terms they are free to leave, to not settle and to pursue the matter in court or in arbitration.   If, however, the parties can all agree on the terms of a settlement, then the settlement is converted into a binding contract (a settlement agreement) that is enforceable.


  1. Communications During Mediation Are Confidential. In California, in order to encourage settlement, the legislature enacted Evidence Code section 1115-1128. These code sections codified the general rule that statements made at mediation are inadmissible at trial. The idea behind this rule is that it encourages parties to talk freely at mediation and to consider settlement, including admission of liability, without fear that any statements or admissions made at mediation will be used against them at trial. Of course, if a party discloses something at mediation that can be then confirmed outside of mediation that can be problematic.


  1. A Mediation Brief is Typically Required. In order to have an effective mediation, most mediators require a mediation brief. A good mediation brief gives an overview of the facts and the law at issue so that the mediator can become very familiar with the nature of the dispute and help the parties resolve their dispute.


  1. It Is Better to Finalize the Settlement Agreement at Mediation. If the parties come to terms on a potential settlement agreement, we think it is far better that the parties finalize the terms of the settlement at the mediation. Otherwise, parties continue to fight over settlement terms and sometimes the parties even have settlor’s remorse.   We recognize that time constraints and extraneous factors sometimes prevent the settlement agreement from being finalized, in those circumstances a deal point memorandum can help resolve future disputes.

Schorr Law’s lead attorney, Zachary Schorr, has participated in hundreds of mediations and knows how to effectively steer parties towards resolving their dispute.   Schorr Law offers representation in mediation and mediation services itself where we use our highly specialized knowledge to help third parties resolve their disputes.   For more information, contact us today.

Share Button
Tagged with: , ,
Posted in Litigation, Mediation

Zachary D. Schorr’s Expert Appearance on the Dr. Phil Show

Zachary D. Schorr’s Expert Appearance on ABC’s Nightline

Contact Schorr Law

Super Lawyers

Zachary Schorr Superlawyers

Zachary D. Schorr has been named to the Southern California Super Lawyers (Rising Stars) list for attorneys in Real Estate for 5 straight years - 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015 and 2016. Each year, no more than 2.5 percent of the lawyers in the state receive this honor. In 2016 he was also included as one of the top 100 lawyers in Southern California in this category. The selection for this respected list is made by the research team at Super Lawyers.

Need Representation?

If you are currently involved in a real estate dispute, either commercial real estate or residential, and are looking for a Real Estate Attorney in Los Angeles with a cost-effective, results oriented approach designed to meet your case's specific needs, contact the attorneys at Schorr Law. Our real estate firm has the specific knowledge and experience necessary to get you the best possible results.

AVVO 10.0

Zachary Schorr Avvo Rating

Avvo Clients’ Choice Award Recipient

Zachary Schorr Avvo Client's Choice Award